Friday, 12 July 2019

Central bank issued cryptos



Terence Zimwara

The crypto-currency race is heating up, giant corporations like J P Morgan, Microsoft, Facebook, Oracle and many others have all signaled their intention to or are in the process of creating their own Blockchain backed currencies.

It seems former skeptics are now taking this financial technology quite seriously; Bitcoin’s resilience has proven that a privately issued currency has its place in a space that has for a long time been closed. So perhaps it comes somewhat as a surprise when central banks also join in the crypto-currencies frenzy.

It is surprising because when Bitcoin was launched, central banks led the charge in vilifying and maiming the currency. Potential users were constantly reminded why this privately issued currency had to be ignored not least because of risks of financial loss. As Bitcoin endured courtesy of the underlying technology, alarmed central banks and their cohorts upped the ante in their opposition.
This currency is being used by criminals or terrorists has been their usual refrain.

Essentially, authorities were alarmed that a privately issued currency was gaining foothold and that this threatened the future of central banks and their monopoly over monetary policy management. Of course, Bitcoin was created specifically to challenge this monopoly and give people a viable alternative to fiat currency.

So it is quite awkward that some 8 years after the start of Bitcoin, the Bank of England signaled its intention to experiment with its own Blockchain backed currency, the so called RSCoin. At the time of the announcement in 2016, the academics working on this project said they hoped this particular Blockchain backed crypto would even upend the US dollar as the world’s reserve currency.

According to media reports at that time, supporters claimed the RSCoin would combine the benefits of distributed ledger technology (DLT) with those of a regular controlled currency. Such are the double standards, apparently crypto-currencies are only beneficial when issued by central banks. The benefits or advantages that are already seen with cryptos like Bitcoin are simply whitewashed.

Indeed many figures in the regulatory world privately acknowledge the utility of the Blockchain technology or DLT and do not want to be left behind. Threats against Bitcoin have not worked, there are now 2000 more crypto-currencies and more will come. The only logical thing is to join the race.
One can only feel sorry for those in the central bank orbit still fighting crypto-currencies; the world has accepted this idea. 

Augustin Carsterns is a General Manager with Bank for International Settlements and a harsh critic of privately issued currency.

Earlier this year he was quoted by the media, railing against crypto-currencies arguing that there are ‘huge operational consequences for central banks in implementing monetary policy and implications for the stability of the financial system.’ 

According to him, central banks thus do not put brakes on innovations (like crypto-currencies) just for the sake of it.

This is rather a belated but important admission, regulators could have been deliberately stifling growth of crypto-currencies this entire time but now ructions within the ranks of central banks beginning to manifest. Switzerland is one country to have gone a step further in embracing Blockchain technology and will probably issue its own central crypto. 

It is clear that reasons often given for the warnings or advisories against Bitcoin are just a ruse; central banks were not happy with the intrusion, they just wanted this space to remain monopolized.
It may be worthy to note that prior to Bitcoin, there had been several attempts to issue currency privately and each time such efforts were crushed.

Abuse of national currency and unchecked printing are some of the inflation causing reasons that motivate individuals to seek alternatives.

Creators of Bitcoin learnt from the mistakes of early currency dissidents and made this decentralized digital currency that seems to give disillusioned fiat currency users a viable alternative. Unless central banks reform, privately issuing crypto-currencies or alternatives to fiat currency will keep coming. It will not matter that central banks are now joining the crypto movement; people will continue to seek alternatives.

Essentially, it this threat or competition from private currencies, which might force central banks to reform after all. Furthermore, it has never been desirable for any entity to enjoy a monopoly position as history has shown us. Therefore central banks can issue their own cryptos but that should not mean an end to privately issued currencies. The more the merrier!

In any market, the quality of choices is only enhanced when there is healthy competition and that should be the case in the currency markets as well.

Bitcoin’s vexing anonymity and confidence



Terence Zimwara

The world’s first privately issued currency, Bitcoin, can be described as a success given the challenges it has survived. There is no doubt that this success will be bettered as events in the financial services world continue to unravel.

Bitcoin has made its point, even harsh critics like Jamie Dimon, the CEO of JP Morgan has been forced to eat humble pie, after initially attacking the crypto. News that JP Morgan will be launching its own crypto vindicates Bitcoin and those behind it in a big way.

However, in spite of this apparent success and acceptance of the ideals of a private currency, the fact that Bitcoin creators still choose to remain unknown is something that still confuses.

It is customary, perhaps even natural, for individuals who bring life changing innovations to seek or expect recognition for their efforts. After all, the geniuses of this world gained global recognition for their innovations, from Bill Gates with his Microsoft to Mark Zuckerberg and his Facebook, Jack Ma with Alibaba to Ren Zhengfei and his Huawei,. Yet with Bitcoin, you cannot put a face to it, Satoshi Nakamoto remains anonymous!

Unfortunately opponents of Bitcoin are seizing on this as they up the ante against the crypto-currency. For example, South African regulators want all issuers of crypto-currencies to register with them so as to gain ‘permission’ to continue operating in that country.

This may well suggest that South African regulators want to know those behind Bitcoin.  Of course, Bitcoin issuers are not going to comply with this, besides it is not possible for any one regulator to grant permission to Bitcoin or to enforce an order banning this crypto. The Blockchain technology behind Bitcoin makes the innovation permissionless, it continues to grow like this because it was created to survive like this.

South African regulators are well aware of this but they are pressing on as the idea is winning the moral argument against anonymous crypto-currencies. Central banks hope to turn the tables against cryptos like Bitcoin, by tying the anticipated refusal to register down to possible ties to money laundering, illicit transactions and terrorism financing.

Of course this terrorism or money laundering argument has run its course but it may well be one of the major reasons why Bitcoin has not reached its full potential. Such a tag saps confidence in that crypto-currency while giving lagging rivals a window to play catch up rather quickly. It could well be true that Facebook studied the Bitcoin Blockchain well and understood the pioneering crypto’s weak points before announcing its entry.

Facebook’s Libra coin is now being touted as a crypto that may finally achieve the elusive dream of greater adoption even as it slated for launch in 2020. Bitcoin did all the hard work, it fought authorities for years to accept the very idea of a privately issued currency and it is now easy for the likes of Facebook to announce it will launch its own.

Authorities now seem to have come around the idea of privately issued currency that is if the United States Congress demands to Facebook are anything to go by. Apparently American congressional leaders want Facebook to assure them that the Libra coin will not be used for nefarious activities something they cannot do with Bitcoin. Of course, in reality politicians have little leverage over Facebook, the congressional hearings are only a pyrrhic victory, and nothing really changes in the end if past hearings are anything to go by.

Powerful politicians are now negotiating with an entity that has not even launched just because they can put a face to the organization. Ideally these powerful politicians should have been negotiating or pleading with Bitcoin! Bitcoin will thus remain handicapped by this anonymity while lesser rivals gain recognition and adoption by the masses.

So while Bitcoin developers and supporters may argue that Libra does meet the minimum standards for a decentralized currency, there is a good chance that those without banking services will embrace it just because they know Facebook, they know Mark Zuckerberg. The social media company has the numbers and many potential users will simply embrace Libra without asking the hard questions like they are doing with Bitcoin or Ethereum for instance.

Bitcoin creators’ insistence on anonymity opens the doors for opportunists as what happened in 2016 when Craig Wright attempted to present himself as Satoshi Nakamoto. This is made possible by the fact that there is no-one or a public relations person that can forcefully dismiss such opportunists.
In Bitcoin’s defence however, this anonymity has been justified given the environment that the currency has had to operate. 

From its inception, the creators recognized the potential of Bitcoin and what it could possibly turn into, and chose anonymity over recognition. Unusually for them, the incentives for going public were outweighed by the cons; possible legal ramifications, personal harassment, liability etc. Some have even suggested that the actual Satoshi Nakamoto may have passed away so the ‘coming out’ that many expect might never happen.

Sadly the situation has changed quite significantly, there is a good chance Bitcoin might become the next MySpace or Yahoo unless some changes are made and that may include revealing the real identities behind this crypto.

MySpace was one of the pioneering social media organizations; it had tens of millions of users especially in North America and enjoyed a leadership position. However that would change when Facebook and Twitter came along. Facebook came with a strategy that was more appealing to a wider audience and its users grew exponentially and the same goes for Twitter. Before long MySpace had been deposed as the number social networking site and today no one remembers much about them.

Similarly, Yahoo was one of the pioneering and dominant email providers but that would change when Google came along. This new kid on block came with its famed search algorithm, emails, videos plus many other services. The result was a familiar, Google upstaged the likes of Yahoo and Hotmail and today there are over a billion Gmail users! Yahoo is now the forgotten email service provider just because it failed to regenerate itself in time.

The idealism behind Bitcoin is almost perfect but now there is a good chance that a rival with diluted principles will enjoy a larger share of the spoils. Bitcoin developers need to do more in order to maintain the momentum and this could mean increasing the block size for instance or the number of coins in circulation or even revealing the actual team behind this innovation. Indeed the threat coming from Libra means Bitcoin creators need to reevaluate the pros and cons of going public.

Achieving mass adoption should be the greater objective hence making sacrifices will be necessary along the way. Bitcoin’s Blockchain has many potential uses but the scaling and numbers issues continue to make it difficult for such potential to be realized. It is time to regenerate the strategy in order for the king of cryptos to continue holding that position.



The controversy surrounding ICOs and crypto adoption



Terence Zimwara

Initial coin offering (ICO), the buzzword in 2017 and early 2018, is a fundraising initiative similar to an Initial Public Offering (IPO) by a company listing on a stock market for the first time. The hype and success of early cryptos kick-started an unusually high request for funding the creation of more crypto-currencies and tokens.

Cryptos are touted as the next big thing after the internet itself and many do not want to be left behind hence the funding requests. So far such funding requests have manifested in the form of ICOs, which raised billions of dollars attracting the interest of global regulators.

Indeed a good number of ICOs were issued during the period of explosive growth in cryptos values. However, prices have since receded and most tokens now trade at well below ICO issuing prices thus severely impairing the value investment portfolios. In other words, if holders of these investment tokens decided to sell they would incur huge losses.

According to a Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) consultation paper, evidence suggests there are particularly significant risks of fraudulent activity associated with ICOs. The FCA is a UK based regulator and consumer protection body.

FCA’s consultation paper quotes a study which ‘showed’ that approximately 25% of ICOs could be fraudulent, whilst other estimates suggest that 46% of ICOs issued in 2017 have already ‘failed.’
The paper adds, “In many cases, investors do not receive what they were promised and issuers do not deliver the intended product or service. This is in part driven by a conflict of interest for the issuer of the ICO, who may seek to maximise the capital being raised by failing to be transparent, not providing sufficient details of the risks, and misleading consumers. In some cases, large sums of money have been raised for projects without appropriate plans or capability for delivery,” concludes the UK watchdog.

From this perspective, it is easy to understand why some view newly created cryptos with suspicion or just as scams. Nevertheless, it is also fair to say that some ICOs have been successful; the funds raised have helped to create outstanding crypto innovations even though token/coin prices remain well below launch levels.

Unfortunately, the narrative has been focused mainly on the former; the entire market needs to be regulated and fast before more investors lose. Conventional financial regulatory bodies want to take the lead in regulating this market even as they do not fully understand the concept of crypto-currency. The result has been these outlandish proposals which are essentially aimed at constraining the growth of this market. Predictably the response by crypto businesses has been that of defiance.

It is important to remember that regulators lack the technology and the know-how to fully control this nascent industry. They will have to rely on the voluntary cooperation by crypto players. If crypto entrepreneurs are unwilling to subject themselves to regulations, there are a few options on the table which regulators can use and these are not 100% effective.

For example, the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe (RBZ) banned banks from dealing with crypto exchanges and at the same time it issued advisories warning members of the public against dealing with crypto-currencies. One crypto exchange, Golix was forced to stop operations and even had an automated teller machine seized.

Nevertheless, that has only forced people who have already embraced crypto-currencies to go underground. Bitcoin trading is going strong despite the ban and the country’s dithering economy—something that can be traced back to RBZ actions—is only helping make the case for wider adoption of cryptos. The verdict seems to be that the RBZ is hardly a suitable candidate to call out crypto-currencies as risky financial assets when its own currency is in shambles!

Zimbabweans are and can still participate in ICOs or whatever fund raising initiative without worrying much about the RBZ. That it pretty much the case in many jurisdictions, regulatory authorities do not have absolute control over ICOs and peer to peer trading.

Sadly however, such haggling between over enthusiastic regulators and sometimes recalcitrant crypto businesses plays a part in slowing the adoption momentum. Fence sitters are easily swayed by the media reports of ICO scams and confidence in cryptos is further shattered when governments skirmish with crypto businesses.

When Golix was forced to shut down in Zimbabwe, it approached the courts for relief and indeed a judgment was handed down setting aside RBZ’s decree.In spite of that, banks still refuse to deal with exchanges and reports suggest clients may have lost funds.

At the very least, Zimbabweans will decide to wait until the dust has settled before embracing cryptos. In worst case scenarios, potential adopters will avoid cryptos completely.

Therefore a middle ground has to be found to enhance confidence in cryptos. Regulators have to acknowledge that they cannot always force regulations if crypto players are unwilling to observe such. Equally crypto players need to acknowledge that without the ‘seal of approval’ from regulatory bodies, confidence in cryptos will remain low and adoption will remain static.

That maybe the direction needed at this particular moment. Already Facebook seems to be attempting this in its engagement with US government officials. The social media giant knows it can still go ahead with its Libra project without ‘approval’ but it wants this endorsement as this will help bring confidence to the coin. Similarly, a tech start-up Denk had its ICO approved by the SEC and this endorsement will go a long way in attracting investors who are otherwise wary of unregulated ICOs.

Sunday, 7 July 2019

Ignorance and complex verbiage: another barrier to crypto mass adoption



Terence Zimwara

Bitcoin is an important innovation that has the potential to end years of dominance by central bank issued currencies. However, in spite of this potential, Bitcoin and other crypto currencies remain on the periphery, in part because potential users are struggling to understand how this sophisticated distributed ledger technology supported currency works.

Not only that, the technical language used within crypto world might also be a big turn-off for potential users. Understandably, the terms and phrases used when discussing Bitcoin are necessary to make the right distinction and for clarity.

 So with this in mind, one might be compelled to conclude that the crypto entrepreneurs might not be doing enough to educate or explain to potential users these terms or phrases. That ignorance levels among the targeted audiences remain very high, some 10 years after launch of Bitcoin, is a serious indictment against advocates of the currency.

 While many crypto news sites do carry contributions from the ‘nerds or geeks’, often these highly intelligent individuals assume that their audiences comprehend issues as well and quickly as they do. So these contributions are often laced incredibly difficult lexicon and concepts.

Such assumptions ultimately act as barriers to effective communication with those of lesser intellect who are in fact the majority. Matters are compounded by the fact that important players like mainstream media are also not capacitated to handle crypto issues or information very well. This important bridge between users and developers remains shaky and ineffective.

For example, in the developing world it is plausible for journalists, just like ordinary folks, to view crypto-currencies with suspicion. Far too many complex get-rich-quickly scams have left thousands counting losses and it is easy to see why crypto-currencies could be viewed similarly.

In any case, it is not easy even for the smart non-IT folks to follow the crypto-currency discourse when complex terms like Cryptographic hash, Elliptic Curve Digital Signature Algorithm (ECDSA) or hard-fork chain split are thrown about in a rather a cavalier fashion.  Such heavy phrases sometimes kill the conversation before it is even starts.

As consequence, the crypto narrative or agenda get easily distorted because media practitioners are either ignorant or find the jargon to be unfriendly to their audiences.

More efforts need to be directed towards filtering the technical language to ensure that anyone who is interested in the subject can follow trends or the latest news. There has to be a way ordinary people can discuss these complex parts of crypto-currencies without getting ‘bored’.

Furthermore, it is important to for the crypto world to communicate directly with the masses. A situation sometimes exists where other forces or non-crypto players seem to be controlling the narrative and this poses many risks.

For example, the death of Quadriga CX CEO and the reports of the subsequent loss of millions of dollars worth of cryptos generated a very negative narrative about the entire crypto market.

After the issue was widely reported by some global media outlets— by journalists who are not very knowledgeable about cryptos— the debate that followed only reinforced the stereotype that cryptos are a scam, a very risky investment or are used by criminals etc.

What do you get when you interview a Wall Street banker about the risks of crypto-currencies? Chances are he will likely assail crypto-currencies and point to the Quadriga CX fiasco as ‘evidence’ of crypto businesses being scams. That is exactly what happened! Journalists covering this story relied on regular financial experts who are just as ignorant to unpack the Quadriga saga. The outcome was predictable.

There lessons here, crypto players must seize the initiative from less the knowledgeable or opponents and control direction of the discourse. Ideally, the debate should be about the utility of Blockchain or the proof of work concept with the crypto players taking the lead in driving this narrative home!

Part of this ‘control’ includes simplifying the complex verbiage and terms as well as repeating the message enough times to make the topic stick. The same way ‘mining’ of crypto coins is seen as critical for the survival of Bitcoin, has to be the same way managing the debate about cryptos should be seen.

The creation of crypto focused media outlets has helped in countering negative storyline but it is perhaps time to invest in pages of mainstream media. The quest to achieve mass adoption means reaching out to readers who are non-crypto enthusiasts but open minded and who may not have the time or interest to visit popular crypto websites but enjoy reading well researched articles. Perhaps this group might listen or even start following the crypto discourse, that is if the topic is regularly discussed in their favorite newspaper like the New York Times or the Bild.

Journalists can only write good articles if they are well capacitated or trained. Educating journalists about cryptos helps to make the topic less difficult to understand as well as eradicating biased reporting.

Merchants embrace key in the quest for wider Bitcoin adoption



Terence Zimwara

The number of merchants accepting crypto-currencies like Bitcoin as a means of payments remains very low. Apparently merchants are only willing to accept cryptos as payment when there are sufficient numbers of who wish to pay this way. When that happens, businesses are likely to even display prices in cryptos but it is still a long way before we get to that stage.

Meanwhile many potential clients will use cryptos increasingly as a payment method when there are enough merchants accepting cryptos as means of payment. No one wants to be stuck with a currency that is not widely accepted. In other words, Bitcoin still has to pass the acceptability test even after being around for 10 years.

The question then arises; what must come first; merchant adoption or general public adoption?
Essentially, the idea must be to make crypto trade or the conversion to and from fiat money seamless, with little to no involvement of intermediaries. When that is achieved, merchants will be attracted to cryptos because of the obvious savings they stand to gain.

In the same way a businessman would reject a currency from a country he barely knows that is the same way he will reject crypto-currencies. He does not want to be trapped with something that he believes no one is willing to accept.

An understanding this means crypto-currencies issuers will have to redouble their efforts at finding a solution that allows for this seamless conversion.

The merchant does not even need to know the complex process of Bitcoin mining or to even download the Blockchain software in order to start accepting cryptos. Their only interest is serving their customers—including those buying with cryptos—well and getting rewarded with a successful purchase. The onus is on crypto entrepreneurs to proffer solutions and already there are products on the market that are doing exactly that. Devices like the PundiX Point of Sale machine, which allows the seamless conversion from Bitcoin to USD, is one potential solution merchants are looking for, if only they are aware of this.

PundiX does exactly what they ask for; it allows the switching from Bitcoin to USD locally. There is no need to involve crypto exchanges domiciled in foreign countries; everything is done locally over the counter by simply swiping a debit card.

So going back to our earlier question, yes it is quite possible for merchants to adopt crypto-currencies first without having to worry about not being able to use these. In fact, a merchant need not understand the complexities of Bitcoin, the POS device does that. The merchant only needs to know how to operate the POS device!

Furthermore, the merchant will not be worried about tax evasion concerns because the device can always convert revenues into legal tender when necessary. Apparently this may be another key concern that is slowing crypto adoption by merchants.  Businesses are wary of possible tax avoidance and evasion allegations should they decide to accept Bitcoin, so a solution like the device mentioned above undercuts such concerns. Government tax agencies will be satisfied as long as they know taxes are being paid regardless of the currency used in settling transactions.

On a different note, the price volatility of cryptos is another key challenge for merchants as well. No one wants to trade in a currency that is unstable. You want to be certain of the value you get before a deal is concluded and that the value stays the same after. So when Bitcoin starts the day at USD11 500 but ends it at USD10 900, this is not ideal for a business that has to make payments to suppliers at the end of that day.

And unless the merchandise is priced solely in crypto-currency—which is even more complicated—there is little rationale for accepting cryptos as payment in the first place. At least that would be the thinking of businesses that refuse to accept cryptos.

Well there is a solution to that too! Today there is a growing list of crypto-currencies or alt coins that address those exact concerns and these are called stablecoin. Bitcoin remains king of crypto-currencies but stablecoins—which are essentially hybrids—have a place in this fight for adoption. 

As the name suggests, stablecoins are created in such a way that they do not fluctuate widely over a given period because the track the value of an underlying asset. The underlying asset can be a commodity or a basket of fiat currencies. True to form, stablecoins like the USD Tether have demonstrated this ability to remain stable; the Tether has maintained a value which is more or less equal to US$1 throughout its lifetime.

Using such a crypto-currency eliminates the volatility risk thus making wider acceptance a real possibility.

Of course there are more advantages to those accepting crypto-currency as payment but ignorance as well as hostility by regulators are stopping potential users from realizing these advantages. Nevertheless, as more people get disillusioned with the fiat currency system, it is imperative for those working to promote the use of alternative forms of money to regularly repeat this message.

·        Crypto payments are prompt and the transactions fees are significantly lower because there are fewer middlemen or intermediaries involved, if any. 

·         Crypto-currencies are usually not subject to exchange control regulations or a particular monetary policy as is the case with fiat money. A business organization can make cross border payments or receive payments from abroad without worrying about the foreign exchange control rules and regulations. Usually such rules compel recipients of payments from abroad to surrender a portion or the entire proceeds at an uneconomic exchange rate. For businesses operating in economically weak countries, an adoption of cryptos means this so-called foreign exchange risk is eliminated.

·        Cryptos are not affected by local inflation trends hence they are a good store of value.

An understanding such advantages means more merchants will start accepting cryptos as payment because they know at the end of the day, they will be able to convert all revenues—using the POS—into a currency that governments recognize. There is zero tax evasion allegation risk, there is zero exchange rate risk and more importantly, there is zero entrapment risk!

Whatsapp 263 771 799 901, @tem2ra, Facebook

Saturday, 6 July 2019

Limited internet access: How this affects crypto adoption in emerging economies




Terence Zimwara

Crypto-currencies might be the next big thing if this nagging problem of limited internet access is addressed. It would appear this is one area where crypto entrepreneurs are floundering, particularly those from developed economies. These entrepreneurs are busy rolling out new tokens, which are usually targeted at potential users in emerging markets where unfortunately internet accessibility remains a challenge.

In many African states, a majority of the population resides in rural areas where provision of essential services, including internet is at best negligible. Yet it is in such rural areas where a big chunk of potential users of crypto-currencies reside. There are fewer or no regular banking services in rural areas when compared with those in urban settings. 

Given this background, it is then easy to see why some cryptos that are designed in Europe but destined for the African market are failing. One has to have a clear understanding of the urban/rural dynamics on the continent—among many other issues— before expecting a crypto to be successful.

Network accessibility and cost remains a challenge in many emerging economies yet availability of the same is vital if greater adoption is to be achieved. Generally, network coverage particularly 3G or 4G is heavily skewed in favour of the affluent, those with access to banking services already (and might not be attracted to alternative forms of banking.)

In other words, Mobile Network Operators (MNO) as well as internet service providers (ISP) will only target remote rural areas if there is a big profit to be made there. On the other hand, rural communities are likely to embrace peer to peer currencies if these become easily accessible.

So an opportunity does exist for both the internet providers and the crypto start-ups, the question is; how can this be exploited for the benefit of both parties?

Indeed some studies show that data usage is increasing in emerging economies. However, a closer look will reveal that tailor made social media data packages are responsible for the general increase in the usage of the internet.

For instance, MNOs offer special data plans for popular social media sites like Facebook, Twitter, Whatsapp or Telegram. Data rates for such packages appear to be cheaper than regular internet browsing costs. In fact, data consumed using these popular social media sites is much higher than data consumed via regular internet browsing.

Perhaps it is with this in mind that many are predicting the Facebook Libra token to potentially be the game changer in as far as crypto mass adoption is concerned. Facebook and Whatsapp are already widely supported by many MNOs because of the sheer number of people using these services. 

Facebook and Whatsapp are popular in both urban and rural settings, which is a major plus.
So unlike Bitcoin, which has faced a myriad of challenges, the Libra token will face far few problems as it is backed by companies with a ‘track record’. There may be no need to invest heavily in education or advocacy as would be the case with many other cryptos, it is simply a question of adding another service to the platform that has more than a billion users. To a Facebook user, it is just a matter of exploring this new service without worrying about data cost. So on that score, Libra may have a head-start in emerging economies

However, there is a downside to the Libra coin, this crypto may not be as permissionless as Bitcoin nor will it be as decentralized. Libra is a hybrid and may not come with everything promised by a crypto-currency like Ethereum for instance. Therefore pioneering cryptos-currencies will still be able to compete well with Libra only if crypto entrepreneurs can solve the internet accessibility challenge. This is a daunting but achievable task.

Perhaps, one way to circumvent this challenge would be to cooperate and coordinate with MNOs in designing data packages and applications for crypto-currencies that are affordable and user friendly. This way, interested/potential crypto users will feel empowered to explore different crypto platforms or to experiment without worrying about data cost. For an MNO, the more users get hooked on a particular application, the better the revenues generated. It is potentially a win-win scenario.

Moreover, crypto businesses should be able to convince MNOs or those managing cellular infrastructure, to deploy in areas where the unbanked are concentrated. Currently crypto-currencies require good internet access for one to perform transactions yet that kind of access is normally available in areas where banking services are widely obtainable i.e. the urban areas.

Meanwhile a prospect of high usage of cellular infrastructure is a tantalizing opportunity enough to encourage an MNO to invest. Perhaps an MNO could be convinced further— to build such infrastructure—if a crypto start-up actually helps or shares the cost burden!

It has happened before, a few years ago, Facebook’s Mark Zuckerberg proposed the idea of giant floating Wi Fi balloons and drones as way that would complement net accessibility in remote areas. Facebook realized that it had to do something to increase the number of its subscribers in remote places. So instead of waiting for an MNO— which might have other priorities—to build the infrastructure, the social media giant came with this proposal.

Crypto players could also take a leaf from this and play their part in building the necessary infrastructure to facilitate a greater adoption of this innovation.

Whatsapp 263 771 799901, @tem2ra, Facebook

Monday, 1 July 2019

Fear of competition behind central bank and regulator hostility towards cryptos



Terence Zimwara

Regulators in some emerging markets have taken a particularly hard-line stance against cryptos just as they have done with other disruptive technologies. The much vaunted mobile money initially faced similar difficulties as officials were unsure of the best way of reacting to this fintech.

In small economies like Zimbabwe, banks in particular were irked by the growth of the Ecocash mobile money platform partly because Econet, the mobile network operator (MNO) operated outside the regulatory purview. At some point soon after the coming on board of Ecocash, banks faced pressure from government over the high bank service charges and fees.

In return, banks argued Econet’s mobile money service had to be subjected to the same pressure since the company had now entered the financial services space. Econet is the biggest MNO in Zimbabwe with over 8 million active subscribers in a country with a population of 13 million. Such numbers potentially made Econet one of the biggest, if not the biggest player in the financial services industry in the country. The fear was that the MNO would use this advantage to elbow out competitors.

To show the seriousness of their fears, banks refused to allow the seamless transfer of funds from banking platforms to the mobile money platform. Conventional bank customers thus could not move funds from their regular accounts to the popular Ecocash platform.

At the time it was not clear who had the mandate to regulate Ecocash, the central bank or the telecoms regulator, Postal and Telecommunications Regulatory Authority of Zimbabwe (POTRAZ). 
Both institutions seemed eager to regulate the MNO. Eventually the RBZ would have its way, mobile money is now regulated by the central bank and commercial banks have since relented as well.

Understanding that MNOs actually complement and do not threat the financial system caused the changed of stance by banks. And as Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe found out, it is easy to impose monetary policies on MNOs because they do not employ decentralized systems like Bitcoin. So instead of fighting mobile money service providers, regulators now encourage use of mobile money platforms.

It is also helpful to remember that the internet itself faced resistance and hostility from players as well as regulators of the industries that felt threatened. However as usage of the internet grew, it became clear to all that the World Wide Web actually enhanced efficiency of the very industries that initially felt threatened. Not only that, the internet brought to life many other services that were not possible before. In fact, the internet has become so integral to our everyday lives such that when its shutdown, life becomes unbearable and chaos will ensue.

Similarly, the extraordinary fear mongering of all things to do with privately issued cryptos will dissipate once a critical mass of users is attained. Change has never been something that is easily embraced, often those agitating for new ways must fight for acceptance. It is now ten years since Bitcoin was launched and we are entering a critical phase, global companies are now joining the movement. JP Morgan, Oracle, Facebook and even central banks have now accepted the concept of crypto-currencies and are working on their own crypto projects.

Many are predicting that the Facebook coin, Libra will be a giant step towards in achieving that elusive mass adoption goal.

Of course some central banks are not happy that the world is moving the direction of cryptos despite their spirited warnings against the embrace of such fintechs.

For less progressive institutions, there are fears that crypto-currencies will ‘infringe upon central banks’ exclusive right to issue money’ as the South Africa Reserve Bank (SARB) put it in a consultation paper. SARB has since proposed measures that may be viewed as circuit breakers in case crypto-currencies become very popular. In other words, SARB does not want crypto-currencies to be successful!

Fear appears to be the general motivation for this hostility and this fear is widespread.
In Kenya, regulators continue to warn citizens about the dangers of crypto-currencies, which are mostly not regulated. Nigeria and Uganda, are both contemplating tough regulation for cryptos, which authorities are repeatedly attempting to link with the growing problem of Ponzi and Pyramid schemes. Regrettably, some ignorant lawmakers associate cryptos with such scams hence they support this hostility.

These central banks are trying to kill an innovation before it has been given a chance to prove itself. In a departure from established norms, regulators are crafting legislation for an innovation before they fully understand it.

However, in other jurisdictions, central banks are embracing crypto-currencies but only on the condition that they alone should be the issuing entities.

For example, a few years ago, the Bank of England was widely reported to be involved in the development of what is called the RSCoin, a crypto currencies which it hopes will eclipse the US dollar as the world’s reserve currency. According to the researchers working on it, this crypto will combine the benefits of Blockchain technology as well as those of a centrally managed currency.

Iran is reportedly working on its own crypto-currency even as it has discouraged the use of other cryptos like Bitcoin. The Venezuelan government has already launched its own crypto but the results have been disastrous so far.

Whichever way we look at it, fear of competition appears to be the prime motivation for the hostility. Central banks do not want to lose their monopoly of issuing money. Unfortunately the world has moved on and its time central banks accept this.

@tem2ra, Facebook whatsapp 263 771799901